Match type
ODI
Teams
England vs South Africa
Gender
male
Dates
Feb 4
Sources
CricketArchive, ECB, ESPNcricinfo, ICC
Status
Mismatch
Number of errors
5

The discrepancies in this match have been identified and can be attributed to the following sources:

  • ECB
  • ICC

The ECB and ICC scorecards are both incorrect in showing Bavuma as scoring 97 off 102 deliveries in the 2nd innings. They are both missing delivery 22.5 in the commentary and seem to be basing their scorecards off that incorrect information, which is causing all of the discrepancies seen for this match.

Discrepancies

Innings 1

Batters

Batting position 5

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 84.47, while ECB, and ICC show 84.46; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter JL Denly Joe Denly Joe Denly Joe Denly
Runs 87 87 87 87
Balls 103 103 103 103
Minutes 144   144  
Fours 6 6 6 6
Sixes 2 2 2 2
Dot balls 48      
Strike rate 84.47 84.46 84.47 84.46
Method of dismissal caught caught caught caught
Batting position 7

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 38.89, while ECB, and ICC show 38.88; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter SM Curran Sam Curran Sam Curran Sam Curran
Runs 7 7 7 7
Balls 18 18 18 18
Minutes 25   25  
Fours 0 0 0 0
Sixes 0 0 0 0
Dot balls 11      
Strike rate 38.89 38.88 38.89 38.88
Method of dismissal bowled bowled bowled bowled
Batting position 8

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 95.24, while ECB, and ICC show 95.23; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter CR Woakes Chris Woakes Chris Woakes Chris Woakes
Runs 40 40 40 40
Balls 42 42 42 42
Minutes 68   68  
Fours 2 2 2 2
Sixes 0 0 0 0
Dot balls 14      
Strike rate 95.24 95.23 95.24 95.23
Method of dismissal caught caught caught caught

Bowlers

Bowler position 4

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 5.88, while ECB, and ICC show 5.87; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Phehlukwayo Andile Phehlukwayo Andile Phehlukwayo Andile Phehlukwayo
Overs 8.0 8.0 8.0 8.0
Maidens 0 0 0 0
Runs 47 47 47 47
Wickets 1 1 1 1
Wides 3   3  
Noballs 0   0  
Dot balls 27 27 27 27
Fours 6   6  
Sixes 0   0  
Economy rate 5.88 5.87 5.88 5.87

Innings 2

Total

This innings has an unacceptable difference noted in the runs shown on each scorecard. For runs, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 259, while ECB, and ICC show 258.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Runs 259 258 259 258
Wickets 3 3 3 3

Batters

Batting position 2

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 42.86, while ECB, and ICC show 42.85; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter RR Hendricks Reeza Hendricks Reeza Hendricks Reeza Hendricks
Runs 6 6 6 6
Balls 14 14 14 14
Minutes 29   29  
Fours 1 1 1 1
Sixes 0 0 0 0
Dot balls 11      
Strike rate 42.86 42.85 42.86 42.85
Method of dismissal caught caught caught caught
Batting position 3

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the balls, runs, and strike rate shown on each scorecard. For balls, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 103, while ECB, and ICC show 102. For runs, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 98, while ECB, and ICC show 97. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 95.15, while ECB, and ICC show 95.09; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is outside that and thus unacceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter T Bavuma Temba Bavuma Temba Bavuma Temba Bavuma
Runs 98 97 98 97
Balls 103 102 103 102
Minutes 150   150  
Fours 5 5 5 5
Sixes 2 2 2 2
Dot balls 42      
Strike rate 95.15 95.09 95.15 95.09
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw lbw
Batting position 5

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 63.64, while ECB, and ICC show 63.63; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Smuts Jon-Jon Smuts JJ Smuts Jon-Jon Smuts
Runs 7 7 7 7
Balls 11 11 11 11
Minutes 19   19  
Fours 1 1 1 1
Sixes 0 0 0 0
Dot balls 7      
Strike rate 63.64 63.63 63.64 63.63

Bowlers

Bowler position 2

This bowler has an unacceptable difference noted in the economy rate, and runs shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 5.6, while ECB, and ICC show 5.4; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is outside that and thus unacceptable. For runs, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 28, while ECB, and ICC show 27.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler SM Curran Sam Curran Sam Curran Sam Curran
Overs 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0
Maidens 0 0 0 0
Runs 28 27 28 27
Wickets 0 0 0 0
Wides 0   0  
Noballs 0   0  
Dot balls 15 15 15 15
Fours 4   4  
Sixes 0   0  
Economy rate 5.6 5.4 5.6 5.4
Bowler position 4

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 5.43, while ECB, and ICC show 5.42; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler TK Curran Tom Curran Tom Curran Tom Curran
Overs 7.0 7.0 7.0 7.0
Maidens 0 0 0 0
Runs 38 38 38 38
Wickets 0 0 0 0
Wides 1   1  
Noballs 0   0  
Dot balls 21 21 21 21
Fours 3   3  
Sixes 1   1  
Economy rate 5.43 5.42 5.43 5.42
Bowler position 5

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 5.54, while ECB, and ICC show 5.53; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler MW Parkinson Matt Parkinson Matt Parkinson Matt Parkinson
Overs 8.4 8.4 8.4 8.4
Maidens 0 0 0 0
Runs 48 48 48 48
Wickets 0 0 0 0
Wides 0   0  
Noballs 0   0  
Dot balls 25 25 25 25
Fours 5   5  
Sixes 0   0  
Economy rate 5.54 5.53 5.54 5.53

Fall of wickets

Fall of wicket 2

This fall of wicket has an unacceptable difference noted in the runs shown on each scorecard. For runs, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 198, while ECB, and ICC show 197.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Wicket 2 2 2 2
Runs 198 197 198 197
Ball 35.1 35.1 35.1 35.1
Fall of wicket 3

This fall of wicket has an unacceptable difference noted in the runs shown on each scorecard. For runs, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 234, while ECB, and ICC show 233.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ECB ESPNcricinfo ICC
Wicket 3 3 3 3
Runs 234 233 234 233
Ball 42.4 42.4 42.4 42.4