Match type
ODI
Teams
New Zealand vs South Africa
Gender
female
Dates
Jan 25
Sources
CricketArchive, ESPNcricinfo, ICC
Status
Mismatch
Number of errors
8

The discrepancies in this match have been identified and can be attributed to the following sources:

  • ICC

ICC scorecard incorrectly lists Bates as facing 76 balls, rather than 75. This is due to a strange quirk in the commentary where the dismissal of Bates is listed twice, basically duplicating the delivery. This error also explains the incorrect total for wickets for Khaka, and the discrepancy in the delivery for the fall of the 4th wicket.

Sadly I'm unable to determine the correct number of minutes for Devine, Priest, and Kerr in the 1st innings, and Wolvaardt, and van Niekerk in the 2nd.

Discrepancies

Innings 1

Batters

Batting position 2

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 73.53, while ICC shows 73.52; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter BM Bezuidenhout Bernadine Bezuidenhout Bernadine Bezuidenhout
Runs 25 25 25
Balls 34 34 34
Minutes 56 56  
Fours 3 3 3
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 73.53 73.53 73.52
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 3

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the balls, and strike rate shown on each scorecard. For balls, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 75, while ICC shows 76. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 70.67, while ICC shows 69.73; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is outside that and thus unacceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter SW Bates Suzie Bates Suzie Bates
Runs 53 53 53
Balls 75 75 76
Minutes 94 94  
Fours 3 3 3
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 70.67 70.67 69.73
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 4

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 87.1, while ICC shows 87.09; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the minutes shown on each scorecard. For minutes, ESPNcricinfo shows 34, while CricketArchive shows 33.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Devine Sophie Devine Sophie Devine
Runs 27 27 27
Balls 31 31 31
Minutes 33 34  
Fours 3 3 3
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 87.1 87.1 87.09
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 5

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 93.98, while ICC shows 93.97; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter KT Perkins Katie Perkins Katie Perkins
Runs 78 78 78
Balls 83 83 83
Minutes 102 102  
Fours 6 6 6
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 93.98 93.98 93.97
Method of dismissal caught and bowled caught and bowled caught and bowled
Batting position 6

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the minutes shown on each scorecard. For minutes, ESPNcricinfo shows 31, while CricketArchive shows 30.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter RH Priest Rachel Priest Rachel Priest
Runs 21 21 21
Balls 22 22 22
Minutes 30 31  
Fours 3 3 3
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 95.45 95.45 95.45
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 7

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the minutes shown on each scorecard. For minutes, ESPNcricinfo shows 12, while CricketArchive shows 11.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter AC Kerr Amelia Kerr Amelia Kerr
Runs 6 6 6
Balls 10 10 10
Minutes 11 12  
Fours 0 0 0
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 60.0 60.0 60.0
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 8

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 181.82, while ICC shows 181.81; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Jensen Hayley Jensen Hayley Jensen
Runs 20 20 20
Balls 11 11 11
Minutes 19 19  
Fours 2 2 2
Sixes 1 1 1
Strike rate 181.82 181.82 181.81
Method of dismissal caught caught caught

Bowlers

Bowler position 2

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 5.63, while CricketArchive, and ICC show 5.62; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Kapp Marizanne Kapp Marizanne Kapp
Overs 8.0 8.0 8.0
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 45 45 45
Wickets 0 0 0
Wides 3 3  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 5.62 5.63 5.62
Dot balls     24
Bowler position 3

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 4.63, while CricketArchive, and ICC show 4.62; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Klaas Masabata Klaas Masabata Klaas
Overs 8.0 8.0 8.0
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 37 37 37
Wickets 3 3 3
Wides 2 2  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 4.62 4.63 4.62
Dot balls     30
Bowler position 4

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 5.38, while ICC shows 5.37; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

This bowler has an unacceptable difference noted in the wickets shown on each scorecard. For wickets, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 3, while ICC shows 4.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Khaka Ayabonga Khaka Ayabonga Khaka
Overs 8.0 8.0 8.0
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 43 43 43
Wickets 3 3 4
Wides 1 1  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 5.38 5.38 5.37
Dot balls     24

Fall of wickets

Fall of wicket 4

This fall of wicket has an unacceptable difference noted in the ball shown on each scorecard. For ball, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 33.3, while ICC shows 33.4.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Wicket 4 4 4
Runs 146 146 146
Ball 33.3 33.3 33.4

Innings 2

Batters

Batting position 2

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 73.39, while ICC shows 73.38; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the minutes shown on each scorecard. For minutes, ESPNcricinfo shows 188, while CricketArchive shows 189.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter L Wolvaardt Laura Wolvaardt Laura Wolvaardt
Runs 91 91 91
Balls 124 124 124
Minutes 189 188  
Fours 9 9 9
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 73.39 73.39 73.38
Batting position 3

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 78.95, while ICC shows 78.94; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter SE Luus Sune Luus Sune Luus
Runs 15 15 15
Balls 19 19 19
Minutes 14 14  
Fours 2 2 2
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 78.95 78.95 78.94
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Batting position 4

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 86.05, while ICC shows 86.04; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the minutes shown on each scorecard. For minutes, ESPNcricinfo shows 49, while CricketArchive shows 48.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter van Niekerk Dane van Niekerk Dane van Niekerk
Runs 37 37 37
Balls 43 43 43
Minutes 48 49  
Fours 4 4 4
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate 86.05 86.05 86.04
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw

Bowlers

Bowler position 2

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 6.31, while ICC shows 6.3; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler HR Huddleston Holly Huddleston Holly Huddleston
Overs 6.3 6.3 6.3
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 41 41 41
Wickets 1 1 1
Wides 2 2  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 6.31 6.31 6.3
Dot balls     21
Bowler position 6

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 4.56, while ICC shows 4.55; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Kasperek Leigh Kasperek Leigh Kasperek
Overs 9.0 9.0 9.0
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 41 41 41
Wickets 0 0 0
Wides 0 0  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 4.56 4.56 4.55
Dot balls     26
Bowler position 7

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 6.86, while ICC shows 6.85; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler SW Bates Suzie Bates Suzie Bates
Overs 3.3 3.3 3.3
Maidens 0 0 0
Runs 24 24 24
Wickets 1 1 1
Wides 1 1  
Noballs 0 0  
Economy rate 6.86 6.86 6.85
Dot balls     10