Match type
Test
Teams
Bangladesh vs Pakistan
Gender
male
Dates
Feb 7 - Feb 10
Sources
CricketArchive, ESPNcricinfo, ICC
Status
Mismatch
Number of errors
4

The discrepancies in this match have been identified and can be attributed to the following sources:

  • ICC

The ICC scorecard is incorrect in having Mominul Haque facing 60 balls in the 1st innings, rather than 59. The miscount appears to happen in the first over in which Haque batted, with the ICC listing him as having faced 3 deliveries after he was in for only 2. This miscount also, unsurprisingly, affects the strike rate.

The ICC scorecard is also incorrect in showing Hossain as facing 8 balls in the 1st innings, rather than 9. This time they are missing delivery 79.2 in the commentary and seem to be basing the scorecard off that incorrect information.

Discrepancies

Innings 1

Batters

Batting position 4

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the balls, and strike rate shown on each scorecard. For balls, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 59, while ICC shows 60. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 50.85, while ICC shows 50.0; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is outside that and thus unacceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Mominul Haque Mominul Haque Mominul Haque
Runs 30 30 30
Balls 59 59 60
Minutes 89    
Fours 5 5 5
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Strike rate   50.85 50.0
Batting position 7

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 71.74, while ICC shows 71.73; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Liton Das Liton Das Liton Das
Runs 33 33 33
Balls 46 46 46
Minutes 64    
Fours 7 7 7
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw
Strike rate   71.74 71.73
Batting position 9

This batter has an unacceptable difference noted in the balls, and strike rate shown on each scorecard. For balls, ESPNcricinfo, and CricketArchive show 9, while ICC shows 8. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 11.11, while ICC shows 12.5; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is outside that and thus unacceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Rubel Hossain Rubel Hossain Rubel Hossain
Runs 1 1 1
Balls 9 9 8
Minutes 9    
Fours 0 0 0
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal bowled bowled bowled
Strike rate   11.11 12.5

Bowlers

Bowler position 1

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 2.43, while ICC shows 2.42; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Shaheen Shah Afridi Shaheen Shah Afridi Shaheen Afridi
Overs 21.5 21.5 21.5
Maidens 3 3 3
Runs 53 53 53
Wickets 4 4 4
Wides 1 1  
Noballs 2 2  
Dot balls 108   108
Fours 6    
Sixes 0    
Economy rate   2.43 2.42
Bowler position 2

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 1.12, while ICC shows 1.11; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

This bowler has an unacceptable difference noted in the dot balls shown on each scorecard. For dot balls, ICC shows 94, while CricketArchive shows 93.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas
Overs 17.0 17.0 17.0
Maidens 9 9 9
Runs 19 19 19
Wickets 2 2 2
Wides 0 0  
Noballs 0 0  
Dot balls 93   94
Fours 2    
Sixes 0    
Economy rate   1.12 1.11
Bowler position 4

This bowler has an unacceptable difference noted in the dot balls shown on each scorecard. For dot balls, ICC shows 93, while CricketArchive shows 94.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Yasir Shah Yasir Shah Yasir Shah
Overs 22.0 22.0 22.0
Maidens 2 2 2
Runs 83 83 83
Wickets 0 0 0
Wides 0 0  
Noballs 0 0  
Dot balls 94   93
Fours 12    
Sixes 1    
Economy rate   3.77 3.77

Innings 2

Batters

Batting position 3

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 57.63, while ICC shows 57.62; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Azhar Ali Azhar Ali Azhar Ali
Runs 34 34 34
Balls 59 59 59
Minutes 94    
Fours 4 4 4
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Strike rate   57.63 57.62
Batting position 5

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 50.39, while ICC shows 50.38; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Asad Shafiq Asad Shafiq Asad Shafiq
Runs 65 65 65
Balls 129 129 129
Minutes 180    
Fours 9 9 9
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Strike rate   50.39 50.38
Batting position 6

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 72.82, while ICC shows 72.81; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Haris Sohail Haris Sohail Haris Sohail
Runs 75 75 75
Balls 103 103 103
Minutes 159    
Fours 7 7 7
Sixes 2 2 2
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Strike rate   72.82 72.81
Batting position 7

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 43.48, while ICC shows 43.47; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Mohammad Rizwan Mohammad Rizwan Mohammad Rizwan
Runs 10 10 10
Balls 23 23 23
Minutes 37    
Fours 1 1 1
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal caught caught caught
Strike rate   43.48 43.47
Batting position 8

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 23.81, while ICC shows 23.8; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Yasir Shah Yasir Shah Yasir Shah
Runs 5 5 5
Balls 21 21 21
Minutes 39    
Fours 1 1 1
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw
Strike rate   23.81 23.8
Batting position 10

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 3.85, while ICC shows 3.84; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas
Runs 1 1 1
Balls 26 26 26
Minutes 44    
Fours 0 0 0
Sixes 0 0 0
Strike rate   3.85 3.84

Bowlers

Bowler position 2

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 2.97, while ICC shows 2.96; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Abu Jayed Abu Jayed Abu Jayed
Overs 29.0 29.0 29.0
Maidens 4 4 4
Runs 86 86 86
Wickets 3 3 3
Wides 0 0  
Noballs 1 1  
Dot balls 134   134
Fours 11    
Sixes 0    
Economy rate   2.97 2.96

Innings 3

Batters

Batting position 3

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 43.68, while ICC shows 43.67; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Nazmul Hossain Najmul Hossain Shanto Najmul Hossain Shanto
Runs 38 38 38
Balls 87 87 87
Minutes 128    
Fours 3 3 3
Sixes 1 1 1
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw
Strike rate   43.68 43.67
Batting position 4

This batter has an acceptable difference noted in the strike rate shown on each scorecard. For strike rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 44.09, while ICC shows 44.08; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the strike rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Batter Mominul Haque Mominul Haque Mominul Haque
Runs 41 41 41
Balls 93 93 93
Minutes 135    
Fours 5 5 5
Sixes 0 0 0
Method of dismissal lbw lbw lbw
Strike rate   44.09 44.08

Bowlers

Bowler position 1

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 2.44, while ICC shows 2.43; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Shaheen Shah Afridi Shaheen Shah Afridi Shaheen Afridi
Overs 16.0 16.0 16.0
Maidens 6 6 6
Runs 39 39 39
Wickets 1 1 1
Wides 1 1  
Noballs 0 0  
Dot balls 81   81
Fours 7    
Sixes 0    
Economy rate   2.44 2.43
Bowler position 2

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 1.87, while ICC shows 1.86; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas Mohammad Abbas
Overs 17.4 17.4 17.4
Maidens 6 6 6
Runs 33 33 33
Wickets 1 1 1
Wides 1 1  
Noballs 0 0  
Dot balls 92   92
Fours 5    
Sixes 0    
Economy rate   1.87 1.86
Bowler position 4

This bowler has an acceptable difference noted in the economy rate shown on each scorecard. For economy rate, ESPNcricinfo shows 3.35, while ICC shows 3.34; and as we have defined an acceptable leeway for the economy rate field as 0.01 this is regarded as a "leeway match", and thus acceptable.

The full details for the compared entry on the various sources are:

Source CricketArchive ESPNcricinfo ICC
Bowler Yasir Shah Yasir Shah Yasir Shah
Overs 17.2 17.2 17.2
Maidens 3 3 3
Runs 58 58 58
Wickets 4 4 4
Wides 0 0  
Noballs 0 0  
Dot balls 79   79
Fours 7    
Sixes 2    
Economy rate   3.35 3.34